Babylon Cheese Cellar

51 Deer Park Ave
Babylon, NY 11702Directions


The Babylon Cheese Cellar is an established cheese shop located in the heart of Babylon Village for 13 years and counting! Our cheese boards, grazing tables, and unique catering options are of the highest quality and second to none.

Why choose The Babylon Cheese Cellar for your event?

Unlike the competition, we source our artisanal cheeses and charcuterie directly from the producers, and can offer you a custom in house tasting to ensure you will love every item we feature on your grazing table or cheese plate! Our cheeses are cared for in shop by skilled cheesemongers who can tell you about the tasting notes, history, or best pairings for each of your cheese selections. 

We are a fully insured caterer and operating within a facility audited by NYS guidelines, an important aspect to consider when looking for a cheese and charcuterie vendor! We are willing to travel or deliver to any venue in the Long Island area, from Nassau to Suffolk (delivery fees apply).

We look forward to creating a memorable cheese experience for you!

The Wedding Industry

The wedding industry offers us the ability to create the most compelling displays of florals, cheese, and salumi - that time and again WOW guests. The wedding industry as a whole allows us to push our creativity to it's max, raise the bar constantly, and impress new customers daily.....and we LOVE THAT! 

We love meeting new couples and discussing their vision for the big day! Working one on one with each bride and groom to taste amazing cheeses and sample our product is one of our favorite parts of the job! During a cheese tasting, couples always learn something new about each other and their culinary preferences :)

Nothing brings people together like cheese.

The Wedding Memories

We were scheduled to create a grazing table for an engagement party where the venue had double booked the event! When we arrived, there was already a party going on in the space we were slated to begin set up! We didn't let that stop us, and had the venue allow us to set a table in a back stock room. We placed our table on furniture movers and just got to work creating the most beautiful grazing table!! 

Once the room was cleared out, we wheeled our table out completely ready to go, lifted and placed it where we were suppose to set up 3 hours prior! It was a crazy, hectic scenario that we will never forget! We honed our skills of thinking on our feet, being problem solvers, and above all making sure the bride and groom were happy!! Event planning is always an adventure and keeps things exciting! 


Cheese platters are our staple and we have created thousands over our 13 years in business. They are perfect for small weddings, engagement parties, getting ready with your wedding party, or for next day brunch/after hour events! 

Company History

Our owners, Tiffany and Anthony, operate The Babylon Cheese Cellar as a husband and wife team!  Anthony began our company as a cheese distributor over 25 years ago, sourcing quality cheese and building valuable relationships in the industry.  He ventually opened our boutique artisanal cheese shop 13 years ago, where Tiffany brought in her professional art training and luxury retail experience. Together we have created a truly special business that offers a custom cheese experience unlike anywhere else. 

BOLI Love!

I got married and we decided to have our reception in my mom’s backyard. One of the best decisions we made was hiring Babylon Cheese Cellar to do a grazing table. From start to finish they were absolutely amazing. We did a tasting with Tiffany and she was brilliant! Her recommendations and attention to detail was incredible. On the day of the wedding they created a stunningly beautiful display that was an absolute show stopper. Not only was the table set up perfection, but the food was fresh and delicious. My guests were talking about this table for days! I would absolutely recommend Babylon Cheese Cellar for your next event!

Toni M.

Babylon Cheese Cellar did the grazing table for our wedding and it was seriously incredible. Not only was it delicious, but it was put together so beautifully by their team. Cannot recommend them enough!

Rosemarie A.

I was obsessed in finding a caterer that did 'grazing tables' out on LI. I was very lucky to find Babylon Cheese. The platters they made for me were absolutely incredible. My experience with Jessica, was just amazing. From the day I came in to plan my platters, up to the point she came to deliver them on party day. She sat with me on planning day for over an hour, picking and choosing cheeses and accompaniments. She was so helpful, and made the very overwhelming task for me, super fun and easy. The platters were just stunning, and a hit with my guests. I live 30 mins away, but they have a customer for life!

Amanda K.

We ordered a charcuterie board from Babylon Cheese Cellar, and it was awesome. They let us sample all the cheeses we asked to try with patience and gave good recommendations. The board looked beautiful, and everything was delicious. We ordered a week ahead and it was fresh, ready when we scheduled to pick it up. We will definitely return!

Sierra L.

Best cheese shop on Long Island!!! I visit frequently and love their selections! They have an amazing fig spread that is out of this world. Their blue cheese selection is the best I've ever come across and I LOVE cheese! They are very friendly and often ask if you would like to try samples! A must-see place for cheese lovers!!

Kelly B.

Fantastic! I've had a few types of cheese from here, and some of their grilled sandwiches as well. I ordered a large cheese platter from them, and now they have "grab and go" cheese platters for one (or two - you get a lot). Everything is delicious, fresh, and these folks know cheese! Would highly recommend.

Susan G.

The cheeses sold here are amazing. We are addicted to coming here even just to browse. Be sure to buy a cheese board (you pick a few cheeses, meats etc). My family devours it in minutes! Oh, the fig jelly is good too.

Jane M.

Wonderful customer service! I told them the wine I was serving, and they had the best recommendations. I went with everything they suggested. I will definitely be back! Thanks ladies!

Shaiema J.

The best spot for cheese, meat, and all the accompaniments on Long Island! Owners and team are so wonderful, extremely kind, helpful and patient.

Nichole D.

We did a girls’ night out and took the Platter Me Pretty class. It was SO MUCH FUN! We learned a lot and ate amazing cheese too. Tiffany was a great host and teacher! I highly recommend the classes and the shop.

Karen L.

Leave BOLI Love!

Submit Your Testimonial