Tellers: An American Chophouse

Tellers: An American Chophouse
605 & 599 Main Street
ISLIP, New York 11751Directions
Website
6312777070

Introduction

Celebrate Your Love Story at Tellers: An American Chophouse

Located in the heart of Islip on Long Island’s South Shore, Tellers: An American Chophouse is where history, romance, and culinary artistry meet. Set within a masterfully restored 1927 First National Bank building, Tellers offers a breathtaking backdrop for weddings, rehearsal dinners, engagement parties, and milestone celebrations. From the moment you step through its grand façade, you’ll feel the beauty, sophistication, and timeless energy that define this iconic venue.

A New Chapter: Tellers Next Door
For a more private and unforgettable experience, Tellers Next Door welcomes guests with a fresh, contemporary feel. Featuring a private entrance and a modern, stylish design, this adjacent space is perfect for rehearsal dinners, engagement celebrations, private wedding events, and so much more. Offering the same elevated cuisine, impeccable service, and refined atmosphere as Tellers, it provides a new canvas to craft your most cherished memories—while maintaining every bit of the sophistication and spirit of the original.

Distinctive Event Spaces at Tellers
Tellers offers a range of stunning, versatile spaces to suit every celebration, each one designed to elevate your event; a few highlights are:

Tellers Next Door's New, Private Spaces

  • The Pavilion: A sleek, semi-private space ideal for weddings, cocktail parties, and grand receptions. With clean lines and a stylish ambiance, the Pavilion can host up to 120 guests for a seated dinner.
  • The Parlor: An intimate, private dining room that provides an elegant setting for up to 60 guests. Perfect for rehearsal dinners, bridal showers, or smaller gatherings where sophistication and intimacy are key.

Or, at Tellers: An American Chophouse

  • The Main Dining Room: The heart of Tellers, featuring soaring ceilings, dramatic lighting, and original marble columns. This magnificent space can host up to 90 guests seated for an awe-inspiring full-venue wedding celebration.
  • The Gallery: Overlooking the dramatic Dining Room, the Gallery offers a semi-private setting full of architectural splendor. Ideal for hosting up to 36 guests for seated events.
  • The Vault: Once the original bank’s safe, the Vault is now a private room full of historic character. With rich textures and exclusivity, it accommodates up to 2 guests for your once-in-a-lifetime proposal, intimate dinner, or anniversary in the most unique of settings.
  • And so much more...

A Historic Setting with Contemporary Allure
From its soaring ceilings and marble columns to its cinematic lighting and expansive bar, Tellers blends old-world grandeur with modern luxury. Every detail of the space has been thoughtfully restored and reimagined, creating a backdrop that feels both timeless and fresh—a stage set for unforgettable moments.

Your Vision, Perfected
At Tellers, no two weddings are alike. Their experienced event team works closely with each couple to craft a fully customized experience, from bespoke menus and curated wine pairings to thoughtful décor and seamless event coordination. Every moment is designed to reflect your unique style and vision.

Culinary Excellence That Elevates Every Celebration
As part of the acclaimed Bohlsen Restaurant Group, Tellers brings an extraordinary culinary experience to every event. Signature offerings include:

  • USDA Prime steaks, dry-aged and hand-cut to perfection
  • Impeccably prepared seafood selections
  • Signature sides like Lobster Mac & Cheese
  • An award-winning wine list and hand-crafted cocktails

Whether you’re planning a plated dinner, a cocktail-style reception, or a festive late-night station, every menu at Tellers is tailored to impress.

Service That Sets the Standard
Exceptional service is the hallmark of every event at Tellers. With professional, attentive staff, sommelier-led wine selections, and white-glove hospitality, your celebration will be orchestrated with care, grace, and meticulous attention to detail—leaving you free to savor every moment.

Plan Your Unforgettable Day at Tellers
Ready to begin your forever in a setting that feels as timeless as your love story? With weddings and special events booking quickly, early inquiries are highly recommended.

BOLI Love!

Tellers is my favorite restaurant, so naturally , I chose it as a venue for my sister's bridal shower. We opted for "The Parlor", an intimate space with beautiful windows, tall ceilings, a private bar, and a second floor bridal suite, which was a perfect area for the bride-to-be to utilize. I knew the day I walked this space that this was the venue. This event would not have been possible without the exceptional assistance of Lisa Esposito. She is attentive, hardworking, and made the day seamless.

Carmen

We have be going to Tellers for many years it has always been a favorite. So naturally It was my 1st choice to have my daughter’s bridal shower there. I met with Lisa Esposito the banquet manager. Her customer service is 2nd to none. I was very impressed with her professionalism and friendly personality. She’s caring,knowledgeable and enthusiastic

Lori V.

Classic, and never go wrong. Any time you need to celebrate, Tellers is one of the only places where you know you won’t have a bad meal. Everything top notch!

Joe

Teller’s Steakhouse is an absolutely stunning and elegant dining experience. From the moment you step inside, the ambiance exudes sophistication, making it perfect for a special night out. One of the most unique aspects of Teller’s is their Vault Room a cozy, intimate two-seater perfect for proposals, anniversaries, or any exceptionally special occasion. If you’re looking for a memorable dining experience with a touch of exclusivity, this is the spot to reserve.

Ariah H.
Click for more reviews

Our experience at Tellers was beyond our expectations: Delicious Food, Impecable Service and engaging ambiance. Definitely We’ll go back.

Maria A.

We had a delicious brunch here celebrating a special occasion. We had the unlimited mimosas that came with three different kinds of juices and a bottle of Prosecco. The food was delicious. The service was excellent, and this was a very good experience.

Liz S.

Alexandra Ardizzone was the coordinator for my engagement party, and I can’t express enough how professional and helpful she was. My family and I can be very indecisive, but Alexandra was incredibly patient with us, maintaining consistent communication up until the event. She was always willing to accommodate any requests, and her support made the entire evening run smoothly and beautifully. I would absolutely host another event here if she were the one overseeing it. The food was praised by all of my guests, and the drinks were not only stunning but also tasted phenomenal.

Courtney D.

I first got to know "Tellers" when a friend celebrated his wedding there. What an incredible venue to enjoy a celebration with family and friends, and the food selection was outstanding. The fresh seafood during the cocktail hour was especially amazing. I’m definitely planning to come back for a drink at the beautiful bar in the other part of the restaurant.

Oliver H.

Leave BOLI Love!

Submit Your Testimonial